GI vs Aluminium Structure for Solar Panels

GI Structure vs Aluminium Structure for Solar Panels – Complete Comparison

When it comes to solar power systems, the mounting structure plays a critical role in ensuring performance, safety, and durability. The structure keeps solar panels firmly fixed at the correct angle, withstanding weather conditions like wind, rain, and temperature changes.

In Pakistan and globally, two main types of mounting structures are commonly used:

  • GI (Galvanized Iron) Structures – with 14-gauge thickness
  • Aluminium Structures – with 2.5mm thickness

Both structures are available in L2, L3, and P1 designs, but they differ in terms of strength, durability, reliability, and cost-effectiveness. Let’s explore their differences in detail.

What is a GI Structure?

GI stands for Galvanized Iron, which is iron or steel coated with a protective layer of zinc. This coating prevents rusting and corrosion.

  • Thickness: 14 gauge (~1.9–2.0 mm)
  • Common Uses: Residential rooftops, commercial systems, ground-mounted installations.
  • Strength: High tensile strength, good load-bearing capacity.

Advantages of GI Structure:

  • High strength and rigidity
  • Cost-effective compared to aluminium
  • Strong resistance to heavy wind loads
  • Widely available in Pakistan

Disadvantages of GI Structure:

  • Heavier than aluminium
  • May corrode if zinc coating is damaged
  • Requires more effort for installation due to weight

What is an Aluminium Structure?

Aluminium structures are made from high-grade aluminium alloys, known for being lightweight, corrosion-resistant, and durable.

  • Thickness: 2.5 mm
  • Common Uses: Premium residential rooftops, commercial systems, coastal areas
  • Strength: Lower tensile strength compared to GI, but highly durable

Advantages of Aluminium Structure:

  • Lightweight and easy to install
  • Superior corrosion resistance (ideal for coastal or humid regions
  • Longer lifespan without rust issues
  • Aesthetically pleasing – clean and modern look

Disadvantages of Aluminium Structure:

  • More expensive than GI
  • Slightly lower load-bearing strength compared to GI (needs proper design to handle heavy winds)
  • Can expand/contract under extreme temperatures (though manageable)

GI vs Aluminium – Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureGI StructureAluminium Structure
StrengthHigh tensile strength, rigidMedium tensile strength
WeightHeavyLightweight
Corrosion ResistanceGood (but coating can wear off)Excellent, does not rust
Durability15–20 years (with good maintenance)20–25+ years
MaintenanceRequires occasional checks for rustVery low maintenance
InstallationDifficult (due to weight)Easy (lightweight, faster installation)
CostMore affordableMore expensive
Best Use CasesGround-mounted, heavy-load rooftopsPremium rooftops, coastal areas
Design TypesL2, L3, P1 availableL2, L3, P1 available

Reliability and Durability

  • GI Structures are reliable for industrial or large ground-mounted systems, where strength and load-bearing are critical. With proper galvanization and maintenance, they last 15–20 years.
  • Aluminium Structures are more reliable for residential and coastal projects, as they are lightweight, easy to install, and offer superior rust resistance. They can last over 25 years with minimal maintenance.

Which One is Better?

The answer depends on project requirements:

  • If strength and affordability are priorities → GI Structure is the better choice.
  • If corrosion resistance, long life, and easy installation are priorities → Aluminium Structure is the best option.

In short:

  • GI = Strong & Cost-Effective
  • Aluminium = Durable & Maintenance-Free

Conclusion

Both GI (14-gauge) and Aluminium (2.5mm) structures in L2, L3, and P1 designs have their place in solar projects.

  • GI structures excel in strength and affordability, making them suitable for large installations and areas with high wind loads.
  • Aluminium structures stand out in durability, corrosion resistance, and ease of installation, making them ideal for residential, premium, and coastal projects.

When choosing between the two, consider location, budget, and system size. A well-selected structure ensures that your solar panels stay protected, efficient, and reliable for decades.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *